Birdseye view of the island of Manhattan with a lot of skyscrapers and bridges

Homeowners Insurance in New York

In New York, whether you own a brownstone in Brooklyn, a condo near Central Park, or a suburban home on Long Island, you face unique risks ranging from hurricanes and nor’easters to high living costs. Homeowners insurance financially buffers you, your family, and your property against such unforeseen events. Without homeowners insurance in New York, these events could lead to significant financial strain. 

The average annual cost of homeowners insurance in New York is around $1,755. So, you must ensure you invest your money in the right policy. Your choice is what will safeguard your investment. 

Whether you’re concerned about natural disasters or everyday accidents, this guide will help you find the best homeowner and New York condo insurance options.

What is the average homeowners insurance cost in New York?

Homeowners insurance costs in New York vary significantly based on location, property value, and other factors. Here’s a look at the average insurance costs in New York in the last five years:

Year

Average Annual Premium

2024

$2,404

2023

$2,257

2022

$1,142

2021

$1,455

2020

$1,356

What factors influence my home insurance rate?

The average cost of home insurance in New York (NY) can vary based on several factors. Here are common aspects that insurance companies use to assess risk and set your rate:

  • Proximity to water: If your property is near the coast or flood-prone, you may face higher policy costs. Insurers charge more because of the increased risk of water damage.
  • Urban density: Living in a city with high crime or fire risks can lead to higher insurance rates. However, being close to a fire station or emergency services might help lower your premium.
  • Construction costs: Rebuilding a home in New York can be expensive due to high labor and material costs, especially in urban areas like New York City. This can result in higher premiums for those living in these regions.
  • Age of the house: The age of your home and any updates made to it can affect your rate. Older homes in New York may need more updates or renovations to qualify for lower insurance premiums.
  • Replacement cost: This is the cost to rebuild your home fully. An appraiser determines this amount to ensure you're covered for the full cost of replacing your home in case of a loss. In high-cost areas of New York, this figure can be quite high.
  • Swimming pool: A swimming pool can increase your liability coverage due to the potential risk of injuries. Pools add risk for accidents, especially in urban or densely populated areas of New York.
  • Home-based business: Running a business from your home might raise your premium to cover inventory, equipment, and supplies. In New York, business activities can add risks that standard homeowners insurance might not cover.
  • Coverage: The type and amount of coverage you choose, including personal property and liability protection, will influence your insurance rate. In New York, more extensive coverage may be necessary due to higher living costs and risks.

Common homeowner insurance discounts in New York

In New York, you might qualify for several discounts on homeowners insurance. Discounts are a great way to lower your NYC home insurance premium. Most insurers offer a variety of discounts, and many are easy to earn. When you get quotes from different insurance companies, ask about any discounts you might qualify for. 

Here are some common discounts you may find with New York homeowners insurance:

  • Loyalty Discount: Many insurance companies offer discounts to long-term customers. If you have stayed with your insurer for several years, you could get a lower rate.
  • Claim-Free Discount: You may receive a discount if you haven’t made any insurance claims for a set period. This reward is for being a responsible homeowner.
  • Military Discount: Some insurers provide discounts for active-duty military members and veterans. If you are or were in the military, ask if you can get this discount.
  • Multi-Policy Discount: You can save money by bundling your homeowners insurance with other policies, like auto insurance. Insurance companies often offer discounts for having multiple policies with them.
  • Safety and Security Device Discount: Installing safety or security devices, such as a doorbell camera or alarm system, can help you save on premiums. These devices make your home safer and reduce the risk for insurers.
  • New Home Discount: If you recently bought a new home, you might be eligible for a discount. Insurers often offer savings for new homes due to updated construction standards and fewer potential issues.
  • Non-Smoker: If no one in your household smokes, you might receive a discount since smoking increases the risk of fire damage.
  • Retiree Credit: If you’re retired and work less than 25 hours a week, you might be eligible for a discount on your home insurance in New York.

Tips for lowering home insurance rates

Even though New York’s insurance rates are generally lower than in other places, you can still find ways to save more. Here are some actionable tips that can potentially reduce your home insurance rates in New York:

  • Look for discounts: Many insurance companies offer discounts. Ensure you follow all the requirements to get the maximum discount on your policy.
  • Adjust your deductible: Increasing your deductible can reduce your monthly home insurance costs. But make sure you can afford the higher deductible if you need to file a claim. Think carefully about this option.
  • Update your home: Improving your home can lower your insurance costs. For instance, a new roof or storm-resistant windows can decrease your risk and potentially lower rebuilding costs. This is especially useful for older homes in New York.
  • Improve your credit: Your credit score affects your insurance rates. Better credit can lead to lower premiums. Work on improving your credit to get better rates.
  • Compare quotes: Shop around for home insurance quotes in New York. Comparing different offers can help you find the best deal. An independent broker can help you with this.
  • Reassess coverage annually: Check your insurance coverage regularly to ensure it meets your needs. Review your policy every few years to ensure you’re still getting a good rate.
  • Consider add-ons: Consider additional coverage for items not included in your standard policy. This might include protection against water backups or extra coverage for valuable belongings like jewelry, which may have limits on theft payouts.

What does New York home insurance cover?

In New York, homeowners insurance typically includes an HO-3 policy, which is a standard form of coverage. This policy protects several important aspects of your home and personal belongings:

  • Home structure: It covers damage to your home's physical structure, including walls, roof, and foundation.
  • Other structures: It also protects other structures on your property, such as fences, garden sheds, and detached garages.
  • Personal property: Your insurance policy covers personal belongings, like furniture, electronics, and clothing.
  • Liability coverage: This helps protect you if someone is injured on your property and you are found legally responsible.
  • Medical payments: It covers medical expenses if someone is injured on your property, regardless of fault.
  • Additional Living Expenses: If a covered event makes your home uninhabitable, this coverage helps with costs for temporary living arrangements.


Although the HO-3 policy is standard, the exact coverage can vary by insurer. Here are some common types of damage typically covered:

  • Theft: Protection against losses from stolen items.
  • Windstorm damage: Coverage for damage caused by high winds.
  • Vandalism: Protection if your property is intentionally damaged.
  • Smoke: Coverage for damage caused by smoke.
  • Fire and lightning: Protection for damage from fire and lightning strikes.
  • Weight of snow and Ice: Coverage for damage due to snow and ice accumulation on your property.

Additional New York insurance coverage options

New York homeowners may face unique risks, like severe winter storms and higher property crime rates. To get the best protection, consider adding these coverage options to your policy:

  • Flood insurance: New York's heavy rain and snowmelt can cause flooding. But standard home insurance doesn’t cover flood damage. You can buy separate flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program, private companies, or as an endorsement with some insurers. If you live in a flood zone and have a mortgage, you might need this insurance.
  • Identity theft coverage: With increasing digital threats, protecting against identity theft is becoming more important. This coverage helps pay for the costs of restoring your identity if it's stolen. 
  • Personal property replacement cost: Standard policies often pay for your belongings based on their current value, which includes depreciation. Replacement cost value (RCV) coverage lets you replace items with new ones of a similar kind. It usually costs only a bit more than standard coverage, so check with your insurance agent about the cost.


Different insurers offer different endorsements. So, check these options to find the best coverage for you.

What coverage is recommended in New York?

New York offers a variety of homeowners insurance options to meet different needs, whether you live in Syracuse or Yonkers. Here are some recommended coverages to consider:

  • Water backup coverage: This protects against losses from backed-up sewer or drain water. It’s useful in areas prone to plumbing issues or heavy rain.
  • Comprehensive dwelling coverage: This ensures you have enough to cover the cost of rebuilding your home if it’s damaged or destroyed.
  • Liability coverage: It’s wise to have at least $300,000 in liability coverage. This protects you in case of lawsuits or claims for injuries or damage that occur on your property.


These coverages can help tailor your insurance policy to better suit your needs and protect against common risks in New York.

Insuring your home in New York

Insuring your home in New York involves several key steps. Here's a simple guide to help you through the process:

  1. Assess your needs: Determine what you need to cover. Consider factors like the value of your home, your personal belongings, and any unique risks like flooding or identity theft.
  2. Research insurance providers: Look for reputable insurance companies that offer home insurance in New York. Compare their coverage options, customer reviews, and financial stability.
  3. Choose the right coverage: Decide on the type of coverage you need. Basic policies often cover fire, theft, and vandalism, but you might need additional coverage for risks like flooding or water backups.
  4. Get multiple quotes: Contact several insurance companies to get New York (NY) homeowners insurance quotes. This helps you compare costs and find the best rate for the coverage you need.
  5. Review policy options: Carefully read the details of each policy. Check what’s included, any exclusions, and the limits of coverage. Make sure it meets your needs and budget.
  6. Ask about discounts: Inquire about any discounts you might qualify for, such as multi-policy discounts or discounts for having security systems. This can help lower your premium.
  7. Complete the application: Once you’ve chosen a policy, fill out the application. Provide accurate information about your home and its condition.
  8. Review and sign the policy: Carefully review the policy documents before signing. Make sure all the details are correct and that you understand your coverage.
  9. Pay your premium: Make the initial payment as required. Insurance companies often offer various payment plans, so choose one that fits your budget.
  10. Keep your policy updated: Regularly review your policy to ensure it still meets your needs, especially if you make major changes to your home or its contents.

Is New York homeowners insurance required by law?

No, New York homeowners insurance laws do not require home insurance. But if you finance your home, your lender can require you to have a homeowners insurance policy. Because of this, it’s best to start shopping for a provider during the escrow process to ensure you end up with a home insurance company that fits your specific needs and so that you can budget appropriately.

Here are some benefits of getting homeowners insurance: 

  • Protection against property damage: Your insurance helps pay for repairs if your home is damaged by fire, wind, or vandalism. This is especially useful in New York, where such events can occur.
  • Coverage for personal property: It covers your belongings, like furniture and electronics, if they are lost or damaged. This is valuable whether you live in a city or a rural area.
  • Liability coverage: This protects you if someone is injured on your property and decides to sue. It's important in places with a lot of people or high traffic.
  • Additional living expenses: If your home becomes uninhabitable because of a covered event, this insurance helps pay for temporary housing. This can be a big help if you need to stay somewhere else.
  • Protection against theft: It helps repay for the losses if your home is broken into. This is particularly important in urban areas where crime rates are higher.

Looking for homeowners insurance in a different state?

Are you interested in learning more about homeowners insurance in other states? Use the map below to look into options across the country.


Still have questions?

Interested to learn more about homeowners insurance in New York (NY)? Here are some frequently asked questions:

Why is homeowners insurance so expensive in New York?

Homeowners insurance in NYC can be expensive due to many different factors. These could include high property values, urban risks like theft and fire, and the state’s susceptibility to natural disasters.

What happens if you don't have insurance in New York?

Without NYC homeowners insurance, you’re at risk of financial loss from damages, liability claims, and lender requirements if you have a mortgage.

Do I need hazard insurance in New York?

Hazard insurance covers specific risks, such as fire and windstorms. It is typically included in a standard homeowners insurance policy.

How much is homeowners insurance in NYC?

The cost of homeowners insurance in NYC varies. However, it is generally higher than the state average due to the increased risks associated with urban living. Average homeowners insurance in New York (NY) typically costs around $1,755

Is it cheaper to rent or own in NYC?

The cost comparison between renting and owning in NYC depends on various factors. These could include property values, rental rates, and personal financial situations. Generally, owning a home usually increases its value over 5-7 years, which can make buying an apartment in NYC cheaper than renting.

How much is New York condo insurance?

Condo insurance in New York City typically ranges from $400 to $700 per year. But, the prices may vary depending on different factors.

How much is homeowners insurance in Long Island, NY?

Homeowners insurance in Long Island typically ranges from $1,500 to $3,500 per year. This is a general estimate, and actual costs can vary significantly based on factors including those mentioned in the blog.

You Deserve Smarter Home Insurance

Quote in 60 Seconds
Hippo

Social Media

Get the App

app QR codeScan me

© 2024 Hippo Enterprises Inc.

Hippo Insurance Services (“Hippo”) is a general agent for affiliated and non-affiliated insurance companies. Hippo is licensed as a property casualty insurance agency in all states in which products are offered. Availability and qualification for coverage, terms, rates, and discounts may vary by jurisdiction. Any estimated premium savings are based on the application of discounts which are subject to availability and qualification. Smart home discounts are subject to additional qualification, conditions, and restrictions. We do not in any way imply that the materials on the site or products are available in jurisdictions in which we are not licensed to do business or that we are soliciting business in any such jurisdiction. Coverage under your insurance policy is subject to the terms and conditions of that policy. Coverage and coverage amounts selected are the decision of the buyer.

Installing and activating the sensor kit will result in your being a customer of a third party that is not affiliated with Hippo. Hippo is not responsible for any acts, errors, or omissions of such third-party or the operation or effectiveness of the sensor kits provided, or any loss or damage of any kind that you may suffer as a result of your installation and use of the sensor kit or engagement with such third party. We encourage you to review the terms of use, privacy notice and any additional notices provided by the third party prior to installing and activating the sensor kit. The terms of your engagement with the third party are solely between you and such third party.